top of page

Neighbor Disputes: Where HOAs Draw the Line

Nov 4
6 min read

Two neighbors are feuding because one says the other’s contractor cracked a decorative planter, somebody keeps taking a shortcut across somebody else’s yard, and neither one has spoken directly to the other for months.


Naturally, they both email the HOA.


By the third message, the community manager has received photographs, screenshots, a hand-drawn property-line diagram, and a detailed history of every unpleasant interaction since 2022.


There is just one problem.


None of it is necessarily an HOA issue.


Living in an HOA does not mean every disagreement between neighbors becomes association business. Sometimes the board or management has a legitimate role. Sometimes the best thing the HOA can do is identify where its authority ends and stay out of the middle.


Knowing the difference matters.


A Neighbor Complaint Is Not Automatically an HOA Complaint


HOAs have governing documents, rules, common areas, maintenance responsibilities, architectural standards, and other areas where the association has authority.


Neighbor relationships are different.


One homeowner may think another is inconsiderate, rude, intrusive, difficult, or simply impossible to live next to. That can make daily life unpleasant without creating anything the HOA can enforce.


At GUD, we believe the first question should be straightforward: What association rule or responsibility is involved? If there is one, management can review it. If there is not, the HOA should be very cautious about stepping into the dispute simply because someone wants an official referee.


The community manager does not keep a whistle in their desk drawer.


Some Neighbor Problems Really Are HOA Problems


This is where the distinction can get tricky.


A barking dog may fall under a nuisance provision. A tree encroaching onto neighboring property may involve an association landscaping standard. Parking, exterior maintenance, architectural changes, drainage, trash cans, pets, lighting, and noise can all potentially fall within the governing documents.


The important thing is not who is annoyed. It is whether the condition itself falls within the HOA’s authority. If a homeowner reports a violation that the association can enforce, the HOA should review it through the normal compliance process.


The complaint does not become more important because the neighbors dislike each other. And it does not become less important for the same reason.


The HOA should address the condition, not referee the relationship.


Some Problems Belong Between the Neighbors


Other disputes are much more clearly personal.


One neighbor says the other damaged a privately owned planter and wants the HOA to make them pay for it.


Someone keeps walking across another owner’s private yard where there is no association easement or common area involved.


Two owners disagree over money from a private arrangement.


One neighbor claims the other is rude, spreads gossip, refuses to speak to them, or sends unpleasant text messages.


Someone wants the board to decide exactly where the private property line sits between two lots.


These situations may be frustrating, expensive, or deeply annoying.


They still may not belong to the HOA.


The association should not become a small-claims court, property surveyor, relationship counselor, or neighborhood truth commission simply because both people happen to own homes in the same community.


Do Not Become the Messenger


One of the easiest ways management gets pulled into a private dispute begins with a seemingly harmless request:


“Can you tell my neighbor…”


Or:


“Can you cite my neighbor for…”


Usually, either one is a warning sign.


If the matter does not involve the HOA, management should not become a communication service between two adults who live thirty feet apart.


Sometimes a direct conversation solves the problem faster than anything management could do.


“Your contractor may have damaged my planter. Can we talk about it?” is a very different starting point from:


“Dear Management, please be advised that Lot 47 has once again demonstrated a complete disregard for neighboring property…”


Once an email begins with “please be advised,” there is an excellent chance the neighbor relationship has already taken a turn.


Give Owners a Clear Answer


Staying out of a private dispute does not mean ignoring the homeowner. Management should still respond.


A useful answer might explain that the concern does not appear to involve an association rule or responsibility and that the owners should attempt to resolve the matter directly.


If another resource may be appropriate, management can point the homeowner in that direction without taking responsibility for solving the problem.


A property-line dispute may require a survey or legal advice. Property damage may be an insurance or civil matter. Trespassing or threatening conduct may belong with the appropriate local authority. Mediation may help neighbors who cannot communicate productively on their own.


The HOA does not need to solve every problem in order to be helpful. Sometimes the most useful response is explaining who actually should.


Do Not Investigate the Relationship


Photos of an actual violation can be useful.


A 19-page chronology titled “History of Problems with My Neighbor” probably is not.


Management and boards should avoid getting pulled into determining who started the argument, who was rude first, who is exaggerating, or which neighbor is generally more pleasant at community events.


Those questions may matter tremendously to the two people involved. They usually do not matter to HOA enforcement.


The association’s question is much narrower: Is there something here that falls within our authority? If the answer is yes, address that issue. If the answer is no, resist the temptation to investigate everything surrounding it.


The board does not need to become Judge Judy.


What Happens When Both Neighbors Start Reporting Each Other?


This is where things can get entertaining.


Neighbor A reports Neighbor B for an actual violation. A week later, Neighbor B suddenly discovers three things wrong at Neighbor A’s property. Maybe it is retaliation. Maybe Neighbor B has simply developed a remarkable new interest in community standards.


Management does not need to decide. Each reported condition should be evaluated on its own merits. If there is a violation, follow the normal process. If there is not, close the matter.


Sometimes both neighbors will be right. Sometimes neither will be. Occasionally, both will receive notices and discover that mutually assured compliance is considerably less satisfying than expected.


The association’s job is not to pick the winner. It is to apply the governing documents consistently.


Condos and Townhomes Can Be More Complicated


The line can be harder to see in condominium and townhome communities because neighbors may share walls, roofs, plumbing, drainage systems, balconies, landscaping, driveways, or other components.


A disagreement that looks private at first may involve a common element, limited common element, or association maintenance responsibility. That is why management should verify responsibility before assuming the HOA has no role.


The same basic principle still applies. Determine what belongs to the association. Address that. Leave the rest to the neighbors.


Board Members Should Stay Out of the Middle Too


Board members face an additional challenge because they often live in the community.


A homeowner spots a director getting the mail and begins with: “Since you’re on the board…” Five words that can make a mailbox feel very far away.


Board members should avoid taking sides, promising action, or offering an unofficial opinion before the issue has been reviewed.


A simple response works: “Please send the concern to management so it can be reviewed through the normal process.” That protects the director, the association, and both homeowners.


The sidewalk is not a board meeting. And the mailbox is definitely not an executive session.


Knowing Where the Line Should Be Drawn


Boards and managers are there to manage association business. That includes enforcing legitimate restrictions, protecting common property, carrying out maintenance responsibilities, administering architectural standards, and helping the community operate according to its governing documents.


It does not include settling every disagreement between the people who live there.


At GUD, we believe management should review the issue, determine whether the association has a role, explain that role clearly, and then stay within it. If there is an HOA violation, address the violation. If there is an association maintenance responsibility, handle the maintenance. If there is a common-area issue, deal with the common area.


But if two neighbors simply cannot stand each other, adding the HOA as a third participant rarely improves the relationship.


Good management sometimes means knowing when to act.


It also means knowing when to say, professionally and politely: “This one belongs to you two.”


Living in an HOA comes with shared rules.


It does not come with a referee.


—Jonathan Brown

Comments


bottom of page